📚 Part of: Constitutional Law And Geographical Knowledge Mcqs: Jammu And Kashmir

Why kashmir was not given to Pakistan

Category: Jammu And Kashmir Gk

Correct Answer: D) Because it was given to disputed area and later given to India.

Exam Relevance: UPSC, Civil Services, State PSC, J&K PSC, History Exams

Difficulty: Moderate

Concept notes:

Jammu and Kashmir's status as a disputed territory stems from the partition of India in 1947. The princely state of Jammu and Kashmir was given the option to join either India or Pakistan. The decision was influenced by the ruler's choice and the geographical and demographic considerations. The accession to India was followed by a UN resolution that called for a plebiscite to determine the will of the people.

Common Mistakes:
  • Believing that the decision was solely based on the ruler's preference without considering the broader political and military context.
  • Ignoring the role of the United Nations in the dispute resolution process.
  • Overlooking the ongoing conflict and the impact of military actions on the territorial status.
Explanation:

The status of Jammu and Kashmir as a disputed territory is a complex issue rooted in the partition of India in 1947. At the time of partition, the princely states were given the option to join either India or Pakistan. Jammu and Kashmir, under the rule of Maharaja Hari Singh, was a predominantly Muslim state with a Hindu ruler. The decision on which country to join was a significant one, influenced by various factors including the ruler's personal preference, the geographical and demographic considerations, and the political and military situation.

Initially, Hari Singh was hesitant to join either India or Pakistan, hoping to maintain the state's independence. However, in October 1947, Pakistani tribesmen invaded the state, prompting Hari Singh to seek military assistance from India. In return for this assistance, Hari Singh signed the Instrument of Accession, formally acceding Jammu and Kashmir to India. This decision was made under the pressure of the invasion and the need for immediate military support.

The accession of Jammu and Kashmir to India was not universally accepted. Pakistan contested the decision, arguing that the state's majority Muslim population should have been allowed to join Pakistan. The United Nations (UN) intervened, calling for a plebiscite to determine the will of the people of Jammu and Kashmir. However, the plebiscite was never held due to the ongoing conflict and the inability of India and Pakistan to agree on the terms of the plebiscite.

The UN resolution, specifically Resolution 47, called for a ceasefire and a plebiscite to be held under the supervision of the UN. However, the resolution was never fully implemented, and the region remains a disputed territory. The conflict has continued, with both India and Pakistan claiming the entire region, leading to several wars and ongoing tensions.

In summary, the status of Jammu and Kashmir as a disputed territory is a result of the complex political and military situation at the time of India's partition. The accession to India was formalized after the ruler's decision and the intervention of the Indian army, but the UN's call for a plebiscite has never been realized, leaving the region in a state of dispute. This situation continues to be a significant point of contention between India and Pakistan, with both countries claiming the entire region as their own.

Option Analysis:
  • Option A: This option is incorrect. The war in Pakistan was not the primary reason for Kashmir not being given to Pakistan. The decision was more complex, involving the ruler's choice, the princely state's geographical and demographic considerations, and the intervention of the Indian and Pakistani armies.
  • Option B: This option is incorrect. While Hari Singh, the ruler of Jammu and Kashmir, did not initially want to join Pakistan, his decision to accede to India was influenced by the invasion of Pakistani tribesmen and the need for Indian military assistance. The decision was not solely based on personal friendship.
  • Option C: This option is incorrect. India's military intervention in Kashmir was a response to the invasion by Pakistani tribesmen and the ruler's request for assistance. The accession to India was a formal process that involved the ruler's decision and the signing of the Instrument of Accession.
  • Option D: This option is correct. Jammu and Kashmir was initially a disputed territory due to the ruler's indecision and the conflicting claims of India and Pakistan. The accession to India was formalized after the ruler's decision and the intervention of the Indian army. The UN later called for a plebiscite, but it was never held, leaving the status of the region in dispute.
⬅️ Back to Constitutional Law And Geographical Knowledge Mcqs: Jammu And Kashmir – Practice all questions