📚 Part of: Indian History And Geography Mcqs: Election Dates, Urban Wealth, And Historical Roads

Jinnah was the first one to accept the Cabinet Mission due to which specific reason?

Category: Miscellaneous Indian Gk

Correct Answer: B) Increase territory was assigned to Muslims (Assam and NWFP).

Exam Relevance: UPSC Civil Services, IAS Prelims, Indian History Exams, Competitive Exams on Indian Politics

Difficulty: Moderate

Concept notes:

The Cabinet Mission Plan was a proposal by the British government in 1946 to form an interim government and a constitution-making body for India. It aimed to resolve the political deadlock between the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League. Jinnah's acceptance of the plan was influenced by the territorial provisions that favored the Muslim League.

Common Mistakes:
  • Confusing the Cabinet Mission Plan with other political agreements of the time.
  • Misunderstanding the specific territorial changes proposed by the plan.
  • Overlooking the significance of territorial expansion for the Muslim League.
Explanation:

The Cabinet Mission Plan, proposed by the British government in 1946, was a significant attempt to resolve the political deadlock in India and pave the way for the transfer of power. The plan aimed to establish an interim government and a constitution-making body, with a focus on the structure of the future Indian state.

The plan proposed a federal structure with three groups of provinces: Group A, Group B, and Group C. Group A included the Hindu-majority provinces, Group B included the Muslim-majority provinces, and Group C included the princely states. The plan also suggested the creation of an interim government and a constitution-making body.

Jinnah's acceptance of the Cabinet Mission Plan was influenced by several factors, but the most significant was the territorial provisions that favored the Muslim League. The plan proposed an increase in territory assigned to Muslims, specifically including Assam and the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP). This territorial expansion was seen as a significant gain for the Muslim League and aligned with their demand for a separate state.

The inclusion of Assam and NWFP was crucial because it provided the Muslim League with a larger territorial base, which was essential for their vision of a separate Muslim state. The Muslim League had been advocating for a separate state, and the territorial expansion offered by the Cabinet Mission Plan was a step towards achieving that goal.

It is important to note that while provincial autonomy and other provisions were part of the plan, they were not the primary reasons for Jinnah's acceptance. The territorial expansion to Assam and NWFP was more significant in influencing Jinnah's decision. The plan did not address the issue of separate electorates, which was another point of contention between the Congress and the Muslim League, but the territorial provisions were seen as a substantial gain for the Muslim League.

In conclusion, the Cabinet Mission Plan's proposal to increase territory assigned to Muslims, particularly Assam and NWFP, was the specific reason for Jinnah's acceptance of the plan. This territorial expansion was a significant factor in the political negotiations leading up to Indian independence and the eventual partition of India.

Option Analysis:
  • Option A: This option is incorrect. Jinnah did not accept the Cabinet Mission Plan primarily due to the issue of separate electorates. The plan did not address the demand for separate electorates, which was a significant point of contention between the Congress and the Muslim League. The focus of the plan was more on the structure of the government and territorial divisions.
  • Option B: This option is correct. Jinnah accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan because it proposed an increase in territory assigned to Muslims, specifically including Assam and the North-West Frontier Province (NWFP). This territorial expansion was seen as a significant gain for the Muslim League and aligned with their demand for a separate state.
  • Option C: This option is incorrect. While provincial autonomy was a part of the Cabinet Mission Plan, it was not the primary reason for Jinnah's acceptance. The plan proposed a federal structure with provincial autonomy, but Jinnah's main concern was the territorial division that would benefit the Muslim-majority areas.
  • Option D: This option is incorrect. Zonal domination to Muslims was not a specific provision of the Cabinet Mission Plan. The plan did propose a grouping of provinces based on religious demographics, but it did not explicitly grant zonal domination to Muslims. The territorial expansion to Assam and NWFP was more significant in influencing Jinnah's decision.

Mnemonic: CAB: Cabinet Mission, Assam, NWFP

⬅️ Back to Indian History And Geography Mcqs: Election Dates, Urban Wealth, And Historical Roads – Practice all questions