Part of: Miscellaneous Indian Gk set 302

Consider the following statements: 1. Unlike other western countries, the Indian Constitution envisages asymmetric federalism. 2. Under Article 371A, the privilege of special status was accorded to the North-Eastern State of Arunachal Pradesh. The correct statement(s) is/are:

Category: Miscellaneous Indian Gk

Hint: Consider the constitutional provisions for special status and the concept of asymmetric federalism.

Correct Answer: A) Only 1.

Exam Relevance: UPSC, SSC, Banking Exams, State PSC

Difficulty: Moderate

Explanations:

Asymmetric federalism is a concept that refers to a system where different states within a federation have different levels of autonomy and rights. This is in contrast to symmetric federalism, where all states have equal rights and powers. In the context of India, the Constitution provides for asymmetric federalism through various special provisions for certain states. This is a unique feature of the Indian federal system, distinguishing it from other Western countries where federalism is typically more symmetric.

One of the key provisions in the Indian Constitution that exemplifies asymmetric federalism is Article 371A. This article provides special status to the state of Nagaland. Under this provision, Nagaland has certain special rights and privileges, including the right to preserve its distinct culture, language, and customs. This is an example of how the Indian Constitution grants special status to certain states, reflecting the principle of asymmetric federalism.

However, it is important to note that the special status provided under Article 371A is not accorded to Arunachal Pradesh. Arunachal Pradesh has its own special provisions under other articles of the Constitution, such as Article 371H, which provides for the preservation of the distinct culture and tradition of the state. Therefore, statement 2 in the question is incorrect.

Understanding the concept of asymmetric federalism and the specific constitutional provisions for special status is crucial for comprehending the unique federal structure of India. It is important to be aware of the specific articles and provisions that apply to different states, as these can vary significantly and reflect the diverse nature of the Indian federation.

Option Analysis:
  • Option A: This option is correct. Statement 1 is true as the Indian Constitution does envisage asymmetric federalism, providing special provisions for certain states. Statement 2 is false because Article 371A provides special status to Nagaland, not Arunachal Pradesh.
  • Option B: This option is incorrect. Statement 2 is false because Article 371A provides special status to Nagaland, not Arunachal Pradesh. Therefore, only statement 1 is correct.
  • Option C: This option is incorrect. Both statements cannot be correct because statement 2 is false. Article 371A provides special status to Nagaland, not Arunachal Pradesh.
  • Option D: This option is incorrect. Statement 1 is true, as the Indian Constitution does envisage asymmetric federalism. Therefore, it is not true that neither statement is correct.

Mnemonic: AFS: Asymmetric Federalism Special

Back to Miscellaneous Indian Gk set 302 – Practice all questions